Gabapentin Is Not a Good Substitute for Rx Opioids
/By Crystal Lindell, PNN Columnist
Gabapentin (Neurontin) is not a good medication for pain relief. If it was, everyone in pain would just take it.
A lot of doctors seem to think it is a direct substitute for opioids though. And it’s leading to a lot of suffering.
A doctor first gave me gabapentin back in 2012. That’s when I started having debilitating pain around my right ribs. I didn’t know it yet, but it was the kind of pain that would never go away.
At the time, I was extremely uninformed on how I’d be treated as a patient with no known cause for my pain. I assumed that because I could point to exactly where the pain was coming from that the doctors would be able to figure out the cause and then fix it. That’s what always happened on House, ER, Scrubs, Grey’s Anatomy, and General Hospital.
When that didn’t happen, I still assumed my doctor would believe me. That, while I sat there crying in his office, confessing my plan to kill myself to escape the pain, at the very least he would give me the most effective medication he knew of for treating the pain.
I was wrong on all accounts.
While my doctor pretended he was giving me the most effective medication he knew of, he instead handed me a prescription for gabapentin.
And I took it. Exactly as prescribed.
He never went over side effects with me, and the list on the pharmacy pamphlet was so long that I assumed most of them were rare. So when I started gaining weight, I blamed it on being home and in pain all the time.
When gabapentin didn’t help with the pain, I went back to my doctor and told him as much. He increased the dose, while assuring me that that was all that was needed.
Wash, rinse, repeat, until I was on the highest allowable dose. Still with no relief.
And to be clear, the pain was awful. It was worse than whatever you just thought of. And it was constant. That’s the killer. It never let up. I never got a break. I’d go days without even minutes of sleep because the pain kept me awake.
The pain was so bad that suicide became a logical treatment option. What’s the point in living a life with no quality in it?
I started showing up at my doctor’s office when they opened, in tears after being awake all night in excruciating pain, asking for help. Still giving my doctor 100 percent of my trust. Still assuming he had my best interest in mind.
I remember sitting on the exam table, wanting to die, while my friend who had driven me to his office at 7 a.m. held my hand. I begged my doctor for help. And he said, “Well what do you want me to do? I can’t up your gabapentin prescription any more. You’re on the max dose.” And then he sent me home.
I didn’t even know enough about pain management at that point to want opioids, much less to know they were being denied to me. I didn’t know the doctors were prescribing a seizure medication because of opioid phobia.
Not long after that, my doctor would break up with me. Or, well, whatever you call it when a doctor says he will no longer treat you and then follows it up with, “So don’t come in anymore.”
He literally gave up. And I would have too, if my pain had gone on much longer.
‘Opioids Saved My Life’
Eventually, I found a new doctor at a university hospital. He believed me. He prescribed me enough opioids to function. And that’s literally the reason I’m still here.
Opioids saved my life. In many ways, gabapentin almost took it.
But it also did something else. It destroyed my trust in doctors and medical professionals. If they could look me in the eye while handing me a prescription they knew wouldn’t help me, what else could they lie about? What else were they hiding from me?
Back then, prescribing gabapentin in place of opioids was a relatively new practice. After that experience, I had hoped it would go away. Instead, it gained traction.
According to data from IQVIA, gabapentin was prescribed over 33 million times in the U.S. in 2011, which is about the time opioid prescriptions peaked. By 2018, the number of prescriptions for gabapentin had increased to over 67 million.
Anecdotally, a lot of people I know with various pain ailments have been offered gabapentin in place of opioids by their doctors as recently as this year.
Since I’m so open when discussing my health issues, it’s common for people I know to ask what my experience was like on various medications. I never know what to tell them when they ask about gabapentin. I’m too worried about being wrong to warn them off of it completely. After all, what if it helps them? I don’t want to keep them from anything that might relieve their pain.
Doctors don’t seem to grapple with this though. For them, addressing patient pain has moved over into optional, right alongside unnecessary cosmetic surgery.
They are literally doing harm. And the practice of giving unproven medication out for pain continues.
Here’s a 2019 article by The New York Times detailing this problem, and the lack of evidence supporting the use of gabapentin for pain.
“One of the most widely prescribed prescription drugs, gabapentin, is being taken by millions of patients despite little or no evidence that it can relieve their pain,” wrote columnist Jane Brody.
In other words, it’s been two years since The New York Times made this clear, but doctors are still prescribing it for pain.
That article misses one key point though. Brody says there are non-gabapentin alternatives to opioids that help pain, but then goes on to list “physical therapy, cognitive behavioral therapy, hypnosis and mindfulness training.”
As a pain patient, I’m here to tell you that none of those are real alternatives to opioids either. While they can all be helpful tools, they can’t replace opioids for real pain relief.
Which brings us to the problem. Our society, with guidance from the CDC, decided to take away everyone’s opioids – without having a real plan to replace them. Because there are no alternatives as good as opioid pain medication.
The general public might worry about their pain treatment if the CDC admitted that. So instead, we are sold a lie about gabapentin. We are told it is just as effective as hydrocodone for all sorts of pain, and that anyone who insists on opioids is just looking to get high.
No matter how much people use gabapentin, physical therapy and mindfulness to treat pain, they just don’t work the way opioids do.
Opioid-phobia is a big messy topic, and doctors replacing opioids with gabapentin are just one small part of that story. But for people who are suffering because of their doctor’s overreliance on gabapentin, it often feels like the most important part.
There’s such an easy answer to this problem too: Just give people opioid medication. When used responsibly, it’s incredibly safe, cheap, and best of all, it actually works.
Crystal Lindell is a journalist who lives in Illinois. After five years of unexplained rib pain, Crystal was finally diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome.
