Should We Diagnose Random Strangers on the Internet?

By Crystal Lindell

I need to say something that is considered controversial in the online chronic illness community: I actually think that we should diagnose random strangers on the internet.

At least sometimes. 

I know, I know. This is the kind of thing most people in the chronic illness community rally against. It’s frowned upon and quickly policed anytime it comes up. 

If you so much as hint that someone with overextended elbows in an Instagram Reel video could have Ehlers-Danlo syndrome (EDS), you’ll get swarmed with comments along the lines of “Don’t diagnose random strangers on the internet!”

But I’m coming to this topic from my own personal experience of being correctly diagnosed by random strangers on the internet. 

After I started writing about my health issues online, readers emailed me to say that they thought I might have EDS. I then took that information to my doctors, who eventually diagnosed me. 

Despite the fact that all of my joints very clearly overextend and that multiple doctors had commented on this to me, none of them even mentioned EDS until I brought it up. So, without the random strangers on the internet, there’s a good chance I never would have known that I have EDS. 

It doesn’t stop there though. Because of that chain of events, many of my family members were also diagnosed with EDS. And someday, future generations might be as well. 

That’s a whole family of people finally knowing what has been afflicting us for generations, and finally understanding that all the chronic health issues we’ve experienced are related. 

There’s power in that, but more importantly there are tangible benefits to it. Knowing that we have EDS and that we are likely to pass it on to our children helps us make more informed decisions about our health in countless ways. 

And it’s all because random strangers on the internet diagnosed me. 

I understand that actively writing about my health issues is not the same thing as people posting random videos on all sorts of topics on TikTok. I get that my content was much more open to the idea of health input from strangers. 

But I would argue that this aversion to diagnosing random strangers online can be harmful to patients. It leads to fewer people knowing what’s wrong with them – and more people thinking that whatever is wrong is some kind of moral failing. 

I do get that EDS, especially the hypermobile type, stands out in this conversation because there are very clear visual markers of the disease. But I don’t think we should stop at EDS, especially in the United States where healthcare is a for-profit industry. I’ll even go so far as to say that I consider it mutual aid to offer free medical advice to others online.

It’s not like we as online commenters are doctors who can prescribe medications to people we’ve diagnosed. Merely mentioning to someone that they may have an illness just opens the door for them to look into that diagnosis themselves and to then bring it up with their doctor. Millions of people have done that after consulting with “Dr. Google” online – usually to the chagrin of their actual doctors.

The idea that it is bad to even comment on a public post about health also serves to continue stigmatizing many illnesses. After all, it’s not a bad thing to have EDS, so why would it be a bad thing to mention to someone online that they could have it? 

Many doctors miss very obvious diagnoses because our for-profit healthcare system mandates that they rush patients through appointments. Their egos also tend to dismiss their patients’ descriptions of their health issues. 

Sometimes the best chance we have is actually random strangers on the internet. 

Now obviously, I need to add an important disclaimer here. If someone specifically says that they do not want medical input, you should listen to them. 

But I would also tell people that refusing medical input could be a bad idea. There is a lot of power in crowdsourcing information. And who knows, random strangers on the internet may just figure out what’s going on with your health before your doctor does. 

If a New Blood Test Can Detect EDS, Will Doctors Even Use It?

By Crystal Lindell

New research points to a potential blood test for hypermobile Ehlers Danlos syndrome (hEDS). But even if the test becomes a reality, I’m skeptical that doctors will use it wisely.  

The study, recently published in the American Journal of Medical Genetics, was funded by the Ehlers-Danos Society. It identifies potential blood-based biomarkers that could help diagnose hEDS, as well as hypermobility spectrum disorders (HSD). 

Researchers examined blood samples from 466 adults, including 94 diagnosed with hEDS and 80 with HSD, and found a protein (fibronectin) with a unique pattern in every participant with hypermobility. 

“The study revealed the presence of a specific 52 kDa fragment of fibronectin in the blood of every individual with hEDS and HSD. This fragment was notably absent in healthy controls, individuals with other types of EDS, and those with various kinds of arthritis,” the Ehlers Danlos Society explained. 

“The consistent presence of the 52 kDa fibronectin fragment in individuals with hEDS and HSD suggests a possible common underlying pathophysiology.”

So basically they found a biomarker that seems to only show up in people with hypermobility, and they are hoping to use this biomarker to create a blood test. The identification of these fragments could lead to the development of the first blood test for hEDS and HSD, providing a more reliable diagnostic tool for healthcare providers.

In theory, this is good news. A blood test would help more people get an hEDS diagnosis, since it’s seemingly more straight-forward than the physical evaluation and family history used to diagnose hEDS now. It currently takes an average of 12 years before someone gets an EDS diagnosis.

However, I’m skeptical about how a blood test would be used in practice. 

Something I always think about is how visually obvious it is that my joints hyperextend. Any doctor who met me should have been on the alert for hEDS within five minutes. And yet, it still took years for me to get evaluated for EDS, and even then it only happened because I pushed for it. 

Shortly after I was diagnosed, I mentioned it to a nurse who I’d been seeing regularly for months for lidocaine treatments and she said, “Oh yes, your elbows do overextend. I see that.” 

Okay, well if you can see it that easily, why hadn’t you ever bothered to look for it? Why did I have to spend months researching EDS myself, and then bring it up to doctors who had never even mentioned it as a possibility?

If doctors and nurses ignore obvious visual markers now, I don’t have much faith that they’ll be proactive in ordering something more arduous like a blood test.  

Not to mention that once there’s a blood test for something, it’s often treated by doctors as both infallible and the end point of evaluation. This happens regardless of how reliable the blood test even claims to be. 

I still remember sitting in an emergency room in my 20’s in extreme pain while the doctor looked me in the eye and said, “It’s definitely not your gallbladder. The blood work for that came back normal.” 

Yeah, but it turned out it was my gallbladder. I was having a gallbladder attack caused by gallstones, which showed up on an ultrasound that I finally got a couple months later. 

But that particular blood test isn't very accurate when it comes to diagnosing gallbladder attacks, as an article from Merck Manual explains: "Laboratory tests usually are not helpful; typically, results are normal unless complications develop."

Whether or not that ER doctor knew that the gallstone blood test was unreliable doesn’t really matter at the end of the day, because he presented the information to me as though the blood test was a perfect indicator – and I believed him. 

The result was that I spent months after that enduring additional gallstone attacks, while waiting for another doctor to override him and order the ultrasound.  

Another time, a medication I was taking was causing excessive bruising on my legs, to the point that there was more black and purple than skin tone. My then-doctor ran blood work and said that “everything was normal.” 

So again, the blood test resulted in a faulty conclusion, because something was definitely abnormal. 

A few years later, when I was finally diagnosed with hEDS, I realized that one of the symptoms is heightened bruising, and thus the medication I had taken had sent that into overdrive. EDS bruising does not always show up in blood tests because it’s not caused by the same factors that cause bruising in other patients. 

If my then-doctor had taken the time to look at the visually obvious bruising on my legs and decided to override the “normal blood work” results, maybe I would have been diagnosed with EDS sooner. 

Make no mistake, I’m glad that there is ongoing research into a blood test for hEDS, and I hope we eventually get one and that it will lead to more people finally being diagnosed. 

It’s just that I don’t have as much faith in doctors as many of them seem to have in blood tests. So I remain skeptical about how it would actually be used in practice.

Eilish, Dunham, Jamil: How Ehlers-Danlos Celebrities Raise Awareness and Scrutiny

By Crystal Lindell

I have to confess that I never watched the HBO Show Girls. It’s not that it looks like a bad show. In fact, almost the opposite. It sounds like a good show. 

But as a young millennial flailing through life when Girls premiered in 2012, I worried that I’d see myself — including my flaws — reflected back at me. And I just have never been in a place, mentally, to process that kind of personal attack. So I didn’t watch Girls.

When the show’s top star and creator Lena Dunham later revealed that she had the same health condition as me — Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS) — it only worked to confirm my fears. 

A lot of people hate Lena Dunham, and a lot of people also hate the character she played on Girls.

What if, through watching the show, I discover that I am like her?

What if I start to believe that I’m worthy of the same level of hate? And in the process, I start to hate myself?

After I was diagnosed with EDS in 2018, Dunham was among the first celebrities I remember seeing reveal her own diagnosis publicly. 

In the fall of 2019, Dunham posted unflattering paparazzi pictures of herself to Instagram — including one of her in a blue granny nightgown, holding a cane in one hand and a cellphone in the other.

LENA DUNHAM

“I could choose to be embarrassed by these paparazzi pics — I mean, that’s probably the point of someone publishing them in the first place — but I’m really not,” Dunham wrote.

“I could lie and say it was an early Halloween look… But the truth is just: This is what life is like when I’m struggling most with chronic illness. An Ehler-Danlos syndrome flare means that I need support from more than just my friends... so thank you, sweet cane!”

A lot of the online EDS community did not take the news well. 

One Reddit user wrote at the time: “Lena Dunham is an extremely problematic and troubled individual. If there is ANY celebrity whose claims — not just regarding illness but regarding all facets of autobiography — should be looked at with a critical and cautious eye, it’s her. She’s not someone we should, as a community, try to turn into a role model or representative for EDS.”

The sentiment summed up what a lot of EDS patients were saying on the internet at the time.

Finally, a celebrity bringing awareness to EDS, and I couldn’t even be excited about it? Instead, I worried that the people who hated her would now hate me too.

JAMEELA JAMIL

The other big name to reveal her EDS diagnosis in 2019 was Jameela Jamil.

And, unfortunately, she’s another celebrity who a lot of people love to hate. 

Two celebrities were out there spreading awareness about the very condition that has caused me immense health problems my entire life, but I couldn’t even post about it online without worrying about haters.

Over the years, a number of other celebrities have also revealed that they have EDS or a related hypermobility disorder, including: Selma Blair, Halsey, Sia, Cherylee Houston, Yvee Oddly and others. 

‘Been in Pain Since I Was Nine’

Most recently, Billie Eilish discussed her hypermobility, a condition often seen as related to EDS, in a recent Vogue profile. At times, she feels like she was at war with her own body.

“I’ve basically been in pain since I was nine,” said Eilish. “Growing up, I’d always hear people be like, ‘Just wait until you’re older! You’re going to have so much pain!’ And I remember being so furious.” 

Bringing EDS into the mainstream and creating awareness should, in theory, help more suffering patients get the diagnosis they seek. Ideally, it would also help lead to more research into the condition, including treatments and maybe even a cure. 

In a perfect world, increased awareness would also lead to more compassion for those struggling with the often painful symptoms of EDS. 

Sadly, over the years, I’ve watched the opposite often happen instead. As EDS has become more well-known, a lot of people have started to see EDS as a trendy diagnosis, the type patients want because they saw that a celebrity has it. 

BILLIE EILISH

In fact, a few years after I was diagnosed at a university hospital, I had a different medical specialist at the same university walk into the exam room and greet me for the first time with, “So what makes you think you have EDS?” 

He asked me as though I had Googled “EDS” on the way to the appointment and then decided to add it to my intake form on a whim. 

In fact, that’s been one of the most jarring things about having EDS. The condition has very obvious visual markers, but people will still try to claim it’s fake. 

My elbow extends way past the normal range of motion. You can’t fake that. 

Every celebrity I’ve seen who’s revealed their own EDS diagnosis has seemed intent on making sure that it is not seen as the most defining thing about them. It’s a truly understandable goal. I don’t want EDS to define me either. 

Unfortunately, EDS has started to be defined by the celebrities who have it: “That Lena Dunham-Jameela Jamil thing.” For better — and sometimes worse — they end up representing our condition in the eyes of the general public. 

While most EDS celebrities don’t have a slew of hate-fans behind them, none of them are fully beloved by the public. And, of course, that’s because being fully beloved by the public is impossible for any human being. 

In fact, all of us are flawed. So in that sense, EDS celebrities are just like us! 

Why a Diagnosis Really Matters When You Have a Chronic Illness

By Crystal Lindell

Trying to get a diagnosis for chronic health problems is like being born with brown hair and dying it blonde your whole life because it feels mandatory. 

Then, after one dye job too many, you start to lose your hair in chunks, so you decide it’s time to get some help. But by then, everyone is invested in you being a blonde. 

You go to the doctor and they look at your dyed blonde hair, which you’ve been maintaining because of societal expectations. And they say, “Umm, you don’t look brunette?” 

Then, despite your very visible brown roots, the doctor accuses you of just wanting the label of “brunette” as a fad. You wonder if he’s right, while your hair falls out from bleach damage.

It took 5 years for me to get an official diagnosis of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) after I started having serious health problems. The kind of health problems that cause you to go from an independent overachiever with 2 jobs and an active social life down to one job, moving in with your mom and spending so much time in her basement that your vitamin D drops to dangerously low levels.

It took me 5 years even though a couple years before I was diagnosed with EDS a doctor added  “benign hypermobility” to my chart. A notation that should have almost immediately led to the Ehlers-Danlos syndrome diagnosis, seeing as how I was clearly having issues that were not benign! 

It honestly makes me want to scream obscenities just remembering it. How casual they were about my life. How dismissive it all feels in retrospect. 

Lurk around any chronic illness patient group online, and you’ll see a similar refrain: Doctors don’t like to diagnose complex chronic health conditions. In fact, patients often have to figure out what they have themselves, and then find a way to present it to the doctor without offending them. I suspect this is why it takes an average of six years to get a diagnosis for a rare disorder. 

Or, if you want to torture yourself, spend time on the Reddit boards for verified medical professionals. There you’ll see the doctors confirming your worst fears: They do think you’re hysterical. They do think you just want attention. They do think the diagnosis that fits your condition is just a fad.

I want to make those doctors understand why none of that is true. I desperately search for the words to make them understand why a diagnosis matters so much when you’re suffering. Even if there’s no cure. Even if it doesn’t change the course of treatment. Even if you’ve already diagnosed yourself.

I grasp at metaphors that fall through the overextended joints in my fingers, desperately trying to make them understand the importance of a diagnosis.

I want to make my case so bad. To use logic and poetry to explain why naming things does actually matter. More than that, I want to make the case for the other patients who are suffering without even being granted the words to explain why.

My pleas fall to the ground though, because doctors don’t listen. Their minds are already made up. It’s all in our heads. And even if it’s not, they say, there’s no point in labeling it. 

They accuse you of just wanting a label to feel special, as though they — as doctors and nurses with their very own set of special letters after their names — aren’t obsessed with labels that make them feel special. 

Worse though, I suspect that somewhere deep down, the doctors know what I know: If a diagnosis did not matter, they wouldn’t be so stressed about not handing them out.

Naming things empower you. It gives you a sense of control over something that’s usually very uncontrollable. But more than that, it gives you the ability to explain it to others. To connect to another human being about your experience.

So yes, a diagnosis does matter. It matters immensely. I just wish I had a single word to explain exactly why. 

Researchers Closer to Finding the Gene for Hypermobile EDS

By Crystal Lindell

We may be one step closer to discovering the specific gene mutations behind hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) — a connective tissue disorder that weakens collagen, muscles, ligaments and organs throughout the body, and makes joints highly flexible.

A research team at the Medical University of South Carolina has released the results of a genetic study of a family with high rates of hEDS. Five out of 11 family members met the clinical diagnostic criteria for hEDS and three were considered “probable.” 

Before we get too far into its conclusions though, it’s important to note that findings were released as a preprint in Research Square, which means they have not yet been peer-reviewed by a journal. As such, it’s in the early stages of release, and further scrutiny may result in changes to the conclusions.

That said, the researchers claim to have found what could be a variant linked to hEDS in the Kallikrein-15 gene, which is primarily expressed in the thyroid gland and other organs.

To check if this gene change actually causes hEDS, researchers used laboratory mice. After modifying the mice to have the same genetic variant, they found that the mice had similar connective tissue problems as seen in people with hEDS.

This supports the idea that the Kallikrein gene changes may play a role in causing hEDS.

But the research does not seem to show an all-encompassing hEDS gene. In a cohort of 197 hEDS patients, they found that less than a third (32.8%) had at least one KLK variant. Which means that over 60% of hEDS patients in the study did not have the variant.

As of now, hEDS is the only type of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome that does not have a known specific genetic marker, so finding one would be monumental. And even if this research doesn’t get us all the way there, it’s a huge step in the right direction.

Previous research has also associated hEDS to a genetic variant that causes a deficiency of folate, the natural form of Vitamin B9.

I should note here that I was diagnosed with hypermobile-EDS in 2018, so I have a lot of interest in the topic on a personal level. Since there is no genetic test currently available for hEDS, I was diagnosed via a physical assessment, along with my family’s medical history.

A lot of hEDS patients worry that if there ever is some sort of confirmed, definitive test like a genetic marker, they may not have the marker and would then “lose” their diagnosis.

Based on my personal experiences with medical professionals, I think that’s a legitimate fear. Doctors already seem unwilling to diagnose clear cases of hEDS for a variety of reasons, and this could just give them another excuse to continue doing that.

All I can really say is that if it happened to me, I would feel confident in knowing that my body is clearly not “normal” — so even if it’s not hEDS, there is something else impacting my health.

Some patients diagnosed with hEDS may actually be suffering from something else -- so a genetic test might help them to get the right diagnosis and treatment. I know that probably sounds naively optimistic to many patients. The more likely result is doctors telling patients nothing is wrong with them, and then sending them on their way to suffer.  

On the other hand, I think hEDS is so under-diagnosed, that having a definitive test for it would result in many, many more people finally getting an hEDS diagnosis.

Discovering the exact gene responsible for hEDS could also result in better treatments going forward. As of now, most doctors tell hEDS patients that there’s no cure, so all they can really do is treat the symptoms as they arise and avoid activities that could make their condition worse.  

This is purely wishful thinking, but perhaps in the future researchers will someday discover a way to actually strengthen our collagen and connective tissue, which could have countless benefits for patients suffering from the pain and other common hEDS symptoms.

Advancements like that still feel a long way off though, so until they happen, helping people get an hEDS diagnosis through a genetic test would be progress for millions of patients.

Colostrum: A Regenerative Hormone for Arachnoiditis

By Dr. Forest Tennant, PNN Columnist

Persons with adhesive arachnoiditis (AA) and other severe painful conditions such as Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) have multiple tissues that become damaged, painful and dysfunctional.

Healing those damaged tissues and reversing the pain and neurologic impairments will require regenerative hormones. This is in contrast to other types of hormones that control inflammation (cortisone), metabolism (thyroid) or sexual functions (estradiol).

The human body makes some natural regenerative hormones, and they are now available for clinical use. Our first realization of their value in treating AA was with human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG). Other regenerative hormones that can be used to treat AA include colostrum, pregnenolone, dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA), nandrolone, and human growth hormone (HGH). We have used all of these and believe that persons with AA should use at least one of them. But our first choice is colostrum.

Colostrum is in mother’s milk produced during the first few days after birth. It contains high levels of tissue growth factors, anti-inflammatories, pain relievers, and anti-infectious agents. Its natural purpose is to allow the newborn baby to initiate growth, protect against infection, and provide pain relief from the trauma of birth.

Colostrum supplements are sold by a number of companies and are usually made from the milk of cows that have recently given birth. Colostrum is recommended for use at least 3 to 5 days a week by persons with AA or EDS, who may wish to double the labeled recommended dosage. Colostrum is non-prescription, relatively inexpensive, and has few side effects. It can be taken with opioids and other drugs.

Regenerative hormones work best when they are used simultaneously with a high protein diet, collagen or amino acid supplements, vitamin C, B12, and polypeptides.

If a person with AA is not doing well or deteriorating, we recommend adding a second regenerative hormone such as nandrolone. A significant reversal of AA symptoms may require one or more regenerative hormones.

Several times a week we get inquiries from people who have just been diagnosed with AA and are pleading for information on what to do. 

The Tennant Foundation recently published an inexpensive short handbook for persons with newly diagnosed AA that gives a step-by-step plan that can hopefully slow progression of this disease.

If you have had AA for a while and aren't doing well, you may still benefit from some of our most up-to-date knowledge and recommendations in the “Handbook for Newly Diagnosed Cases of Adhesive Arachnoiditis.”

Forest Tennant, MD, DrPH, is retired from clinical practice but continues his research on the treatment of intractable pain and arachnoiditis. This column is adapted from bulletins recently issued by the Tennant Foundations’s Arachnoiditis Research and Education Project. Readers interested in subscribing to the bulletins should click here.

The Tennant Foundation gives financial support to Pain News Network and sponsors PNN’s Patient Resources section.  

How Realistic Is a Possible Treatment for Hypermobile EDS?

By Crystal Lindell, PNN Columnist

Ever since I was diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hEDS) back in 2018, I’ve spent countless hours contemplating what my life would be like if there was an effective treatment.

Last week, Tulane University School of Medicine pushed that question to the forefront. They announced that they may have found a potential cause of hEDS and hypermobility in general. They also theorized a potential treatment.

Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS) creates fragile connective tissue, which can cause a range of other symptoms including joint pain, digestive trouble, migraines and more.  

Tulane researchers proposed that a variation of the MTHFR gene that causes a deficiency of folate – the natural form of vitamin B9 – could hold the key to hypermobility and a range of connective tissue disorders such as EDS. As for treatment, they hypothesized that methylated folate — which is folate that is already processed — could be a possible treatment for the myofascial pain that’s common for hypermobile patients. They published these preliminary findings in the journal Heliyon.

First, it should be noted that none of this was based on a clinical study of patients. Rather, it’s a proposal that they believe should be researched further. As such, there’s been some valid criticism of Tulane’s announcement from the EDS community. Was it premature? Will any of this hold up in a peer-reviewed study? Or are they just giving false hope to the thousands of EDS patients desperate for some good news?

As an EDS patient myself, I understand those concerns and I very much sympathize with them. Many of us have spent too much time being dismissed by doctors, and too much money on treatments that don’t end up working.

Unfortunately, I think we’re going to have to live in the uncertainty right now. We won’t know if this is a viable option until we get a peer-reviewed study. But I am glad that they are looking into this and sharing these types of updates as the research progresses. I’d rather be informed along the way than only be told at the end of the process.

What Would a Treatment Mean for Patients?

What if their theory is correct though? Is that a good thing? I have to confess, my feelings about it are complicated.

The thing about EDS is that it’s different for everyone. As it stands, most doctors treat the symptoms, which, as mentioned above, vary widely. For me, the most debilitating one is intercostal neuralgia — which is not a type of myofascial pain. As such, it seems unlikely that methylated folate would do much to treat it.

But hey, maybe methylated folate is more of a preventative treatment? That alone would be an incredible advancement for hEDS patients.

The question is, would this treatment impact anything else? Do they know if it would only address myofascial pain? Or could it also help with other symptoms? And would that even be a good thing if it did?

EDS touches every aspect of my body and even most aspects of my personality. There’s the velvety skin everyone comments on when they shake my hand. And the constant comments about how I look for my age, which also seems to be related to how EDS impacts my skin. Would methylated folate treatment change that at all? How so? And what would I end up looking like?

The most well-known EDS symptom is probably loose joints, which means they easily overextend. For me, that’s meant a lifetime of sprained ankles and joint pain. But again, what happens if methylated folate changes that? My joints may be loose, but they’re the only ones I’ve ever known. Would stiffening them up actually help me at this point? Or would I have to re-learn how to move my own body?

What about my mind? EDS patients have higher than average rates of neurodivergence like autism and ADHD. They also have higher rates of mental health issues like depression and anxiety. Could this treatment change our brains too? Or, if not, what if they eventually find a treatment that does? Would it alter aspects of people’s personalities?

There’s also the more logistical issue of EDS as a name at all. According to the National Library of Medicine, a syndrome refers to a group of symptoms and physical findings without a direct cause. Once a cause is found, the symptoms are typically renamed as a “disease.” So, if the researchers at Tulane did find a cause, what do we have? Ehlers-Danlos disease? EDD?

One thing we do know is that EDS and hypermobility cause immeasurable pain and suffering for a lot of people, so we do need more research into potential treatments. Time will tell if folate treatment proves effective or not, but either way, I hope that there are a lot more potential treatments coming.

Crystal Lindell is a freelance writer who lives in Illinois. After five years of unexplained rib pain, Crystal was finally diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. She and her fiancé have 3 cats: Princess Dee, Basil, and Goose. She enjoys the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Taylor Swift Easter eggs, and playing the daily word game Semantle. 

Researchers Find Possible Cause of Hypermobile EDS

By Crystal Lindell, PNN Columnist

Do we finally have a genetic link for hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome?

Researchers at Tulane University School of Medicine think so – and it could even point to an effective treatment that’s already available.

A variation of the MTHFR gene that causes a deficiency of folate – the natural form of vitamin B9 – could hold the key to hypermobility and a range of associated connective tissue disorders such as Ehlers-Danlos (EDS), according to preliminary findings published in the journal Heliyon.

“You’ve got millions of people that likely have this, and until now, there’s been no known cause we’ve known to treat,” said Gregory Bix, MD, director of the Tulane University Clinical Neuroscience Research Center. “It’s a big deal.”

People with the genetic variant can’t metabolize folate, which causes unmetabolized folate to accumulate in the bloodstream. The resulting folate deficiency in other parts of the body prevents key proteins from binding collagen to the extracellular matrix, which plays an important role in cell growth. This leads to more elastic connective tissue, hypermobility, and a potential cascade of associated conditions, researchers said.

The discovery could help doctors more accurately diagnose hypermobility and hypermobile EDS by looking for elevated folate levels in blood tests and the MTHFR genetic variant.

“Hypermobility is widespread and unfortunately under-recognized,” said Jacques Courseault, MD, medical director of the Tulane Fascia Institute and Treatment Center. “I’m excited about being able to treat the masses where people aren’t going their whole lives being frustrated and not getting the treatment they need."

Doctors discovered the connection between folate deficiency and the MTHFR gene by working with patients at Tulane’s Hypermobility and Ehlers-Danlos Clinic, the only clinic in the U.S. that focuses on fascia disorders. Blood tests of hypermobile patients revealed elevated levels of unmetabolized folate. Subsequent tests showed that most of those with elevated folate serum levels had the MTHFR genetic variant.

The good news is a treatment already exists. Methylated folate – folate that is already processed – is FDA-approved and widely available.

“It’s an innocuous treatment,” Bix said. “It’s not dangerous, and it’s a vitamin that can improve people’s lives. That’s the biggest thing: We know what’s going on here, and we can treat it.”

“We’ve discovered something in medicine that can help, not a small group of people, but potentially many across the world.”

— Dr. Jacques Courseault

Though more studies and clinical testing needs to be done, researchers say patients who have been treated with folate have shown improvement: less pain, less brain fog, fewer allergies and improved gastrointestinal function.

“We’ve discovered something in medicine that can help, not a small group of people, but potentially many across the world,” Courseault said. “This is real, it’s been vetted out well and clinically we’re noticing a difference.”

What Is Hypermobile EDS?

For those with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), the same conditions that create fragile connective tissue can cause a range of other symptoms that, on the surface, can seem unrelated: joint pain, chronic fatigue, thin tooth enamel, dizziness, digestive trouble and migraines, as well as psychiatric disorders such as anxiety and depression. Women with hypermobile EDS may also be at increased risk for endometriosis or uterine fibroids.

For years, researchers have struggled to find the cause of hypermobility and hypermobile EDS. Of the 13 subtypes of EDS, hypermobile EDS comprises more than 90 percent of cases. But until this study, hypermobile EDS was the only subtype without a known genetic correlate. As a result, symptoms have often been treated individually, without EDS being recognized as the likely cause.

Until now, hypermobility could only be diagnosed by the Beighton score, a somewhat controversial physical exam that involves measuring the bend of the spine, fingers and limbs. There has also been a historic lack of acceptance of hypermobility as a disorder that requires specialized treatment.

Many patients with hypermobile EDS never get a proper diagnosis. As a result, the number of people with hypermobility is unclear, though it could comprise more than half the world’s population.

“Hypermobility is not rare,” Courseault said. “Hypermobility is like a Ferrari that requires a lot of maintenance and the best synthetic oil. After knowing a patient's name and date of birth, I think it's prudent for clinicians to know which of these body types they have.”

Crystal Lindell is a freelance writer who lives in Illinois. After five years of unexplained rib pain, Crystal was finally diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. She and her fiancé have 3 cats: Princess Dee, Basil, and Goose. She enjoys the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Taylor Swift Easter eggs, and playing the daily word game Semantle. 

Hypermobility Linked to Depression and Anxiety at Young Age

By Madora Pennington, PNN Columnist

The teenage years are difficult for almost everyone, but even more so for teens with hypermobile joints, a condition known as hypermobility. Their joints have an excess range of motion, and some can literally bend their arms, legs and fingers backward.

Jess — who asked that we not use her last name — had always noticed she was extremely flexible. By the time she was a teenager, Jess had crushing fatigue and anxiety. She obsessed over her grades like a perfectionist and developed an eating disorder. Her terrible anxiety caused her to self-medicate, as she did all she could to keep up with her peers.

Eventually, it all became too much. Jess had to leave high school and finish her degree through proficiency testing. Not until age 19 was she finally diagnosed with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), a disease that weakens connective tissue in the joints and causes hypermobility.

Hypermobility in early life is normal. All babies and children are highly flexible, which most eventually outgrow. But for some children, hypermobility is permanent. Excessively loose joints are a feature common to many inherited disorders like EDS, wherein the body cannot make connective tissue that is stable and strong. In essence, the "glue" holding their bodies together is flawed and weak.

Extremely flexible people like Jess may be seen by their peers as having interesting or cool skills, like doing contortionist tricks or excelling in yoga. But hypermobility is a severe health problem that can lead to mental health issues.

"Hypermobility affects one in four people in the UK. Like other musculoskeletal conditions, it can have a profound and far-reaching impact on life, causing daily pain, fatigue and often disrupted sleep," says Dr. Neha Issar-Brown, Director of Research and Health Intelligence at the UK-based charity Versus Arthritis. "Previous studies in adults have shown that you are more likely to suffer from anxiety if you have hypermobility, and that the daily toll of painful symptoms can lead to depression.”

A new study in BMJ Open found a similar link in adolescents. To see if there is an association between hypermobility, anxiety and depression in late adolescence, researchers at Brighton and Sussex Medical School evaluated over 14,000 teens with joint hypermobility.

At age 14, their hypermobility was scored, which is done by measuring the degree to which various joints hyperextend or bend past the point where they should. Then, at age 18, the participants answered surveys about depression and anxiety. Pain, a common complication of hypermobility, was also taken into account. The participants' heart rates were also studied.

"Many psychiatric problems, including depression and anxiety, start before the age of 25. It is therefore important to identify the factors that may increase the risk for these disorders. Being aware of the link between hypermobility and depression and anxiety means that we can work on developing appropriate and effective treatments," said lead author Dr. Jessica Eccles, Department of Neuroscience, Brighton and Sussex Medical School.

Eccles and her colleagues found that young people with joint hypermobility were more likely to have depression and anxiety, and their psychiatric symptoms were also more severe. Joint hypermobility was more common in females than males, but it was only among males that hypermobility increased the risk for depression.

"This study has highlighted the need for more targeted and bespoke support for hypermobile teenagers, particularly girls," says Lea Milligan, CEO of the UK-based advocacy organization MK Mental Health Research. "The findings don't just show the need for support for this group of individuals, but also demonstrate the importance of research that takes a whole mind, body brain approach to health and uses longitudinal studies to improve our understanding of which demographics are at higher risk of depression and anxiety.”

Why hypermobile people suffer from more psychopathologies may be due to a dysregulation of the nervous system called dysautonomia, which is very common among those with loose joints. Their poorly regulated nervous systems cause a rapid increase in heart rate when they rise to stand, when it should remain constant. This inability of the body to maintain a smooth and consistent heart rate when posture changes has also been associated with anxiety.

Rapid heart rates and poor cardiovascular regulation also occur when someone has anxiety and depression. The higher a person's resting heart rate, the more psychological symptoms tend to follow. Those with depression tend to have different skin temperatures, breathing rates, and a lower variability in heart rate.

Complaints from UK parents with hypermobile children motivated this study. They encountered healthcare providers that were ignorant of the complications and challenges of hypermobility and dismissed their concerns. More awareness and education are needed to help these families, and this study is a step in that direction.

Madora Pennington is the author of the blog LessFlexible.com about her life with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. She graduated from UC Berkeley with minors in Journalism and Disability Studies. 

Medical Gaslighting of Woman for Being of 'Childbearing Age' Goes Viral

By Madora Pennington, PNN Columnist

After seeing a neurologist earlier this month for cluster headaches, Tara Rule’s doctor walked her to the front desk. She thanked him. Then, in her car, she burst into tears. Instead of treating her pain, the doctor turned the appointment into a lecture about a hypothetical pregnancy that she didn't want. He had made her feel so horrible, she wanted to die.

“I can’t keep living in world where it is a game to them,” she said to herself.

Feeling hopeless and alone, Rule pulled out her cellphone and, tears streaming down her face, recorded a video recounting what had just happened and how she felt about it.

It is rare to actually see the raw, visceral reaction to medical gaslighting, and how it affects someone’s self-worth and mental health. Many patients leave such appointments doubting themselves, often becoming unwilling to seek medical care as the medical traumas add up.

Rule, 31, is already on disability from a lifetime of complex medical problems, including Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), a connective tissue disorder.

When she realized her appointment at a Glen Falls, New York hospital was going sideways, she reached into her bag and began an audio recording with her cellphone. New York allows single party consent to recording, so she didn't need to have the doctor’s permission.

Rule was trying to keep it together, despite her intense pain from debilitating headaches. She wanted the recording so she could sort out what happened later. She wanted to make sure her PTSD from past medical trauma was not triggering her, possibly causing her to misunderstand the doctor.

TARA RULE

In the recording, Rule’s neurologist said he would not give her a certain medication to treat her headache. His reason? She could get pregnant and that particular drug — which he did not name — can cause birth defects. So he doesn't prescribe it to women of "childbearing age."

Rule pushed back, pointing out she is already on a medication for an autoimmune condition that can cause birth defects and miscarriages. And because EDS is a genetic disorder, she does not want to have a child and risk passing it on. Plus, a pregnancy could be harmful for her health.

Instead of making the appointment about Rule's pain and her need for treatment, she says the doctor asked her intrusive questions about her sex life. He disregarded the medical information she provided and patronizingly suggested she might change her mind if she were pregnant. He also insisted her sexual partner would have to consent to her being treated with the unnamed drug.

Rule posted her anguished video on TikTok, and it soon went viral. She's received countless messages from others who have been through similar encounters. While it made her feel less alone, it saddened Rule deeply to learn how many people have stories like hers. The media took notice with articles on Jezebel and in the Albany Times Union.

Severe headaches and cranio-cervical pain are commonly seen in people with EDS, an inherited failure of the body to produce strong collagen. Rule has suffered from migraines since she got a concussion at age eight. Her cluster headaches started in 2016.

“They are a whole different beast,” she told me. “The pain is indescribable. It doesn’t let up. It won’t go away.” Rule says she is a happy person who is not suicidal, but pain like that makes you wish you weren’t alive.

Rather than treat the suffering patient in front of him, the neurologist prioritized a hypothetical situation, in which Rule's birth control fails and she winds up pregnant. For him, this fantasy scenario was more important than giving her the best medical option for pain relief.

Rule complained to the hospital, which apologized and began an investigation. She also created a petition to end doctors' ability to deny treatment to women because they might get pregnant. So far, over 25,000 people have signed it, making it one of the most popular petitions on Change.org.

“As a living, breathing human being who exists, I feel it is absurd that doctors who are expected to provide the best, most effective care and treatments to their patients are able to deny effective treatments due to the potential for birth defects in patients of child bearing age who are not currently pregnant,” she wrote in the petition. 

The week after her botched meeting with the neurologist, Rule found herself in throes of horrendous head pain and took herself to urgent care. She was receiving an IV and oxygen when a group of doctors and security personnel marched into her room. She panicked, thinking of when she was told she had lesions on her brain. Were these people coming to give her bad news like that?

No, the staff was not here to provide medical services. They had come to discharge her. The hospital Rule had complained to apparently called other clinics in the area about her. The urgent care personnel accused her of livestreaming the appointment with her neurologist, which she did not. Nonetheless, they wanted her out immediately. She tried to give the desk her new insurance information as she left, but the staff had closed the window and simply stared at her.

“Shouldn’t they be putting that doctor on leave rather than track my social media and call hospitals? It’s scary,” she told PNN.

Now Rule is afraid to seek medical care. Most of the facilities in her area are owned by that hospital system. Her primary care doctor is part of it. She is not sure if any of them will see her.

“I’m on disability. I have no money. Am I going to have to move?” she wonders.

Madora Pennington is the author of the blog LessFlexible.com about her life with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. She graduated from UC Berkeley with minors in Journalism and Disability Studies. 

'Bend or Break' Raises Awareness About Invisible Illness

By Madora Pennington, PNN Columnist

Even though he was just a kid, people called Mitch Martow lazy. Too exhausted to maintain friendships and falling asleep in school, his classmates thought he was strange. Specialists couldn’t find a medical reason for his complaints, and psychiatrists had no answers either. Even morphine didn’t ease the pain that tortured him in his early teens.

One day, worn out from physical suffering that was compounded by so many doctors saying his pain was a mental issue, Mitch attempted suicide. He cried when he awoke in the ICU because he had not succeeded.

This is the story told in the documentary “Bend or Break.” Based mainly on Mitch’s blog posts, the film features interviews with Mitch and his family about how his mysterious illness turned their lives upside down and how a correct diagnosis changed all of that.

Mitch has Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), a term for a number of similar, poorly understood disorders where the body fails to make stable collagen. As a result, the person has extreme flexibility, to the extent that their joints can bend backward.

With no obvious outward signs, many of us with EDS go decades without a diagnosis, despite frequently seeking care for its debilitating and perplexing symptoms.

MITCH MARTOW

When he was finally diagnosed correctly, Mitch’s family was troubled because EDS is under-researched and lacks effective treatments. For Mitch, his diagnosis made him happy: he was not crazy and could find others like him, which meant everything. It was the end of isolation.

To tell the story, Bend or Break showcases a young contortionist and dancer, Toria Summerville. Toria also has Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, so she is capable of astounding feats of flexibility. Interspersed with the interview segments are Toria’s beautifully choreographed dances that express the emotionality of the Martow family’s experience.

‘I Felt Very Alone’

Toria was 19 when she participated in the documentary, but her performance has the maturity and depth of someone much older. From childhood, she always knew she was different but didn’t know why. With no understanding of what was wrong, it was up to her to get by and cope with unacknowledged and unaddressed symptoms.

When she was 5 or 6 years old, Toria would be awake all night, crying in pain. Doctors said it was growing pains. When she was in the 6th grade, she was put on medication for anxiety and depression. Doctors assumed she had an eating disorder, but she was allergic to many foods, a common problem with EDS.

“I felt very alone growing up and very confused with myself. I knew something was going on, but I didn’t know what,” Talia says.

She struggled with brain fog and fatigue. Her differences attracted comments from other kids, which felt like bullying. In dance class, others would laugh at her inability to control her superhuman flexibility.

Toria was often getting injured with dislocating joints and easy bruising. Concerned guidance counselors would ask if anyone was abusing her. Well-meaning adults put her in a peer support group, but she could not relate to the other kids. There, therapists offered helpful tools, but they were not what Toria needed, so it felt even more isolating.

At a performing arts high school, Toria found understanding. Her circus coach instinctively understood her and took her under his wing. “We worked on abilities that my body could do,” she says.

For Bend or Break, Toria dedicated herself to understanding and demonstrating what the Martow family experienced, a process that was emotionally challenging, not only because of what Mitch went through but because much of it hit close to home. She walked a fine line.

“I had to be sensitive that it was Mitch’s story, not mine. I had to be in tune with all the milestones he was going through and portray that with my movements and facial expressions,” she explained.

In one sequence, she dances in a straitjacket, an idea she came up with from the feeling of being trapped by so many misdiagnoses herself.

Bend or Break concludes with interviews of others with EDS. Like Mitch, they look perfectly healthy. No one would guess how debilitating their EDS problems are. The documentary drives home the difficulty of having an invisible illness — one not indicated by obvious signs of impairment. People with invisible illnesses and disabilities have a hard time getting believed.

Toria hopes Bend or Break will spread awareness about EDS to the general population and medical professionals in every field. Had she been diagnosed correctly at an earlier age, Toria could have avoided many injuries and gotten better help in school.

“We need to cut back the time to get a diagnosis. My life would have been a lot easier if I had known about EDS sooner,” she says.

Mitch has seen firsthand the positive effects Bend or Break is having. Medical doctors have thanked him for the film because it helped them understand patients with EDS or other invisible illnesses. He’s also spoken to psychology students who have watched the film and is hopeful that when they start working as mental health professionals, they’ll be cautious about insisting that a patient’s chronic pain is psychosomatic.

The film encourages healthcare providers to be careful with diagnoses like "conversion disorder," where a symptom is assumed to be mental because no physical cause can be found. Being treated that way nearly destroyed Mitch’s life. “I tried to use suicide to escape from it,” he says.

Madora Pennington is the author of the blog LessFlexible.com about her life with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. She graduated from UC Berkeley with minors in Journalism and Disability Studies. 

Why Antibiotics Can Lead to a C. Diff Infection

By Madora Pennington, PNN Columnist

Got antibiotics? Then you may be on your way to a dangerous and potentially deadly infection. When antibiotics alter the balance of intestinal flora, a bacteria that causes diarrhea and inflammation of the colon -- clostridioides difficile -- can take over and result in a C. diff infection.

That is what happened to Kristy Collins. It took two rounds of antibiotics to clear up her severe ear and sinus infection. A few days later, a lunchtime salad left Kristy with a strangely upset stomach. She thought it was nothing more than a bit of food poisoning, but soon she was having malodorous belches and the foulest smelling diarrhea. She also became severely dehydrated.

At first, her doctor suspected a stomach virus. But when her stomach troubles didn’t relent, a stool test revealed that Kristy had C. diff.  Luckily, she was diagnosed and treated within a few days.

Because she has Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), an inherited chronic illness, Kristy is a seasoned patient with a medical team in place. But having EDS also makes her more like to get C. diff. Thus far, she has had 19 surgeries for EDS-related problems. Most surgical procedures require a round of antibiotics to prevent infection and more if an infection occurs after surgery.

After her bout with C. diff, Kristy needed another surgery. She and her doctors were very concerned about a possible C. diff recurrence, as about 1 in 5 patients will get another infection. Kristy’s doctors tested her after surgery to ensure it had not returned.

Kristy worries whenever she needs antibiotics and questions her doctors if they are truly necessary. She already follows a very healthy diet, which helps manage her chronic illness and suspects this may be part of why she has not had a C. diff recurrence. She also follows her doctors’ advice.

“It was the first time doctors told me to take probiotics,” Kristy says, which she did while taking antibiotics. Probiotics are living microorganisms that enhance intestinal health. They are found in fermented food like yogurt and sauerkraut or made into supplements.

Antibiotics tend to alter that flora in the colon, creating an environment where C diff can flourish. Many people have immune systems that can handle a C. diff infection without symptoms, but others get very ill with watery diarrhea that may contain blood or mucus, or cause nausea, vomiting, loss of appetite, abdominal pain, and bloating. At its worst, C. diff can cause a loss of blood circulation, sepsis, perforated bowel, or swelling so severe it shuts down the colon.

It is not just antibiotics that can cause a C. diff infection. Other possibilities are chemotherapy treatment, proton pump inhibitor medications (usually used to treat acid reflux), kidney or liver disease, malnutrition, or simply being an older person. C. diff infects approximately half a million Americans annually, according to the CDC. 

C. diff can also be fatal. In the U.S., nearly 30,000 people die every year from a C. diff infection. Diagnosis is usually made by testing a stool sample. It is treated with antibiotics, monoclonal antibodies, or, in severe cases, surgery.

How to Prevent C. Diff

Good hygiene practices can help prevent its spread. For C. diff, hand washing with soap and water is more effective than using alcohol-based hand sanitizers. It is also essential to limit the use of antibiotics to situations when they are truly necessary, to avoid disrupting the balance of bacteria in the colon. Many doctors recommend repopulating the beneficial bacteria with probiotic supplementation during or after antibiotic treatment.

Recovering from a C. diff infection can be mysterious as well as complicated. Many patients are not advised on how or what to eat or drink. Food can seem like the enemy, and meals can feel traumatizing.

To address this unmet need, the Peggy Lillis Foundation, a non-profit advocacy organization created in honor of a beloved kindergarten teacher whose life was taken suddenly by C. diff, recently published a nutrition and lifestyle guide.

 “This guide begins to address the dearth of information by combining medical expertise, dietary guidance, and first-hand knowledge from C. diff survivors,” says Executive Director Christian John Lillis.

The guide is sponsored by probiotic manufacturer Bio-K Plus and put together by the PLF’s Scientific Advisory Council. It covers tips on managing the acute phase of a C. diff infection, preventing a recurrence, improving gut health, dealing with the emotional implications of C. diff, and recipes. It is available to download free by clicking here.

Madora Pennington is the author of the blog LessFlexible.com about her life with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. She graduated from UC Berkeley with minors in Journalism and Disability Studies. 

What’s Missing in ‘Elvis’ Movie: The King’s Chronic Illness

By Pat Anson, PNN Editor

There’s a scene towards the end of the new “Elvis” movie when you know the end is coming soon. Presley, as depicted by actor Austin Butler, collapses in a hallway minutes before being scheduled to take the stage at the International Hotel in Las Vegas.

Instead of rushing an unconscious Elvis to a hospital, manager Tom Parker --- played by a surprisingly villainous Tom Hanks -- declares that the show must go on and summons “Dr. Nick” to make it right. After a quick injection of stimulant drugs, Elvis recovers just enough to sing, dance and entertain an adoring crowd in a packed showroom.   

That one scene sums up how the real Elvis Presley spent his final years before dying of an apparent heart attack in 1977 at the young age of 42. Popping pills. Slurring his words. Deeply depressed. And driven to continue performing by “Colonel” Parker and others.

“They really tried to push Elvis beyond his capacity in the last few years of his life. He was disabled,” says Dr. Forest Tennant, a retired physician and pain management expert who is one of the last people alive to be intimately familiar with Elvis’ drug use and medical problems.

In 1981, Tennant was hired by an attorney for Dr. George Nichopoulos (Dr. Nick), who faced criminal charges in Presley’s death. Tennant reviewed the autopsy report, medical records and a confidential 161-page private investigation, and testified as a defense witness for Nichopoulos, who would be acquitted of charges of overprescribing drugs.

After the trial, Tennant remained curious about Elvis’ medical problems and continued his research while treating people with intractable pain. The knowledge and experience Tennant gained in the last 50 years led to his recent book, appropriately titled “The Strange Medical Saga of Elvis Presley.”  

Elvis did indeed suffer from heart problems aggravated by an excessive use of drugs, but Tennant believes the ultimate cause of his death was a connective tissue disorder called Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), a major cause of intractable pain and other chronic health problems.

A diagnostic screening tool for EDS didn’t exist when Elvis was alive and few physicians were even aware of the condition. But Tennant thinks Presley had all the symptoms of EDS, including an unusual degree of flexibility and double jointness that allowed him to swing his hips and gyrate wildly. Those sexy dance moves helped make Elvis famous, but they also foretold what lay in store for him.

“EDS is a genetic connective tissue collagen disorder, and what that means is that you are genetically predetermined to have your collagen in certain tissues either disappear or deteriorate or become defective, and to put it bluntly, you can have a rectal problem and an eye problem at the same time due to the same cause because your collagen is deteriorating in these tissues,” Tennant told my colleague Donna Gregory Burch in a 2021 interview. “If you get a severe case like Elvis Presley, your life is going to be very miserable, and you're going to die young unless you get vigorous treatments.”      

The day before he died, a dentist gave Presley codeine for an aching tooth, not realizing how sick he was or that codeine could cause his heart to stop. Elvis collapsed in the bathroom 24 hours later. His sudden death led to rumors that he died from an overdose or even a horrible case of constipation. The truth is more complex.

“Nothing happened to Elvis Presley that we don't have a good logical, scientific explanation for now. But certainly back in those days we didn't,” Tennant explained. “Elvis Presley had multiple diseases. He was terribly ill, and he died accidentally in some ways with a dentist giving him codeine for his bad tooth, and his bad teeth were also part of the same disease that gave him a bad colon and a bad eye and a bad liver. They were all connected.

“He had all these metabolic defects due to his genetics, and so the codeine built up in his system. He had this terrible heart, so he died suddenly, within seconds, as he was trying to sit on the commode.”

Fortunately, the “Elvis” movie spares us any final scenes like that – ending instead with actual clips from one of Presley’s last concerts. They show a tired and very sick man, aged beyond his years and sweating profusely. But he still sang like “The King.”

All proceeds from sales of “The Strange Medical Saga of Elvis Presley” go the Tennant Foundation, which gives financial support to Pain News Network and sponsors PNN’s Patient Resources section.

The Inside Story of Elvis Presley’s Death

By Donna Gregory Burch

When Elvis Presley first hit the music scene during the 1950s, he was both beloved and vilified for the hip-thrusting, leg-shaking and gyrating that changed the art form of musical performance forever.

But what many don’t realize is that Presley’s ability to do those iconic dance moves came with a cost and may have actually contributed to his sudden death in 1977 at the age of 42.

In a new book entitled “The Strange Medical Saga of Elvis Presley,” Dr. Forest Tennant, a retired physician who specialized in pain medicine and addiction treatment, explores the fascinating medical history of Elvis.

Turns out, it wasn’t all those peanut butter, banana and bacon sandwiches that killed him. But what did?

I recently had a chance to interview Tennant about his latest book and what really caused Elvis’ death.  

Donna Gregory Burch: When I think about Elvis’ death, I recall the rumors that he died while taking a bowel movement on the toilet and that his autopsy revealed a very full colon. Are either of those stories actually true?

Forest Tennant: Yes, they are. We knew about these events [surrounding his death], but we had no scientific or medical explanation as to why they occurred. Fifty years after he dies, we finally have a scientific explanation as to why he died like he did.

What happened to him and why he died so suddenly in the bathroom was … a medical controversy that … ended up in a criminal trial and with all kinds of emotionalism.

Nothing happened to Elvis Presley that we don't have a good logical, scientific explanation for now. But certainly back in those days we didn't.  

You were involved in a court proceeding about Elvis’ death. Could you tell me about that and what role you served during the lawsuit?

Well, what happened was that because he died suddenly and because the pathologists couldn't agree on why he died, and because Elvis was found to be abusing drugs as well as being prescribed a lot of drugs, a criminal trial was brought against his physician (Dr. George Nichopoulos).

The attorney that decided to defend (Nichopoulos) was a man by the name of James Neal, who was a federal prosecutor who prosecuted Jimmy Hoffa and the offenders in the Watergate scandal, and so he was the nation's top attorney at that time. He investigated the case and found out that the doctor that treated Elvis Presley was not a criminal at all and was doing his best to help him.

Some dozen physicians at the Baptist hospital in Memphis saw Elvis Presley, but nobody knew what was the matter with him. They knew he had some kind of mysterious, systemic disease, which is a disease that can affect multiple organs at the same time.

He was a baffling medical case for the doctors in Memphis at that time, and we didn't know what he had up until about three or four years ago. We did not understand the genetic collagen connective tissue disorders, now usually referred to by doctors as Ehlers Danlos syndrome (EDS). Nobody understood that his glaucoma and his colon [issues] were connected [due to EDS]. They knew it was connected somehow but they didn't have an explanation for it at that time.

What do we know today about why Elvis died that we could not explain back when he actually passed away?

He had a severe heart problem.

Elvis’ heart problem was directly tied to his diet, right? I mean he was well-known for his fat and sugar-laden diet.

Yes, his diet was part of it, but his autoimmunity also affected his heart.

But the major controversy of the day is one that's maybe a little hard for the public to understand. A drug overdose in 1977 was said to only occur if the lungs filled up with fluid. He had no fluid in his lungs, so the only thing that he had at his autopsy of any significance was a huge heart. And so the pathologist and the county medical examiner said he had to have died of a heart attack because his heart was so bad.

The catch was that he had about 11 drugs in his bloodstream. The highest level was codeine, so there became a dispute among the doctors. A certain group of pathologists who were highly qualified said he died of a heart problem. Another group of highly qualified physicians who were called forensic pathologists said no, he died of his drugs. Up until about two or three or four years ago, the argument was still going on.

Now, I hate to say thanks to the opioid crisis, but because of the overdose deaths that have occurred in recent years, a lot of studies have been done, and enzymes have been discovered, and metabolism has been discovered showing that drugs like codeine can cause a certain heart stoppage without having pulmonary edema (fluid filling the lungs].

It turns out that 24 hours before he died, a dentist gave him codeine. He was already thought to be allergic to it anyway, and that was because he had all these metabolic defects due to his genetics, and so the codeine built up in his system. He had this terrible heart, so he died suddenly, within seconds, as he was trying to sit on the commode. He fell forward.

There is a forensic pathologist, the best one of the day, called Dr. Joseph Davis, and in about 1997, he described exactly, second by second, what happened to Elvis in the bathroom. But the cause is pretty clear: He took the codeine, and it caused a cardiac arrhythmia. If he had a good heart, he might have survived, but he had a bad heart.

So, it’s really a combination. You had these two sides of doctors arguing – they even ended up in a criminal trial – but it turns out that they were both right. It was a combination of a terrible heart and a drug that causes cardiac arrhythmia, and that's why he died with no pulmonary edema.

So many times in the medical community, we always look for that one cause, right? His case is very illustrative. Because the body is so complex, it's often multiple factors that are causing health issues.

Elvis Presley had multiple diseases. He was terribly ill, and he died accidentally in some ways with a dentist giving him codeine for his bad tooth, and his bad teeth were also part of the same disease that gave him a bad colon and a bad eye and a bad liver. They were all connected.

EDS is what connects all of those health problems, correct?

Yes, scientifically, EDS is a genetic connective tissue collagen disorder, and what that means is that you are genetically predetermined to have your collagen in certain tissues either disappear or deteriorate or become defective, and to put it bluntly, you can have a rectal problem and an eye problem at the same time due to the same cause because your collagen is deteriorating in these tissues, and you were programmed to develop this when you are born. It is a major cause of the intractable pain syndrome.

Now some of the diseases are very mild. You have a little double jointedness, and your skin is a little lax, and you might develop some arthritis, but you become a good gymnast in the Olympics or you become a good football player in some of the mild cases. But if you get a severe case like Elvis Presley, your life is going to be very miserable, and you're going to die young unless you get vigorous treatments, which are being developed right now.

I don't think EDS was even recognized back when Elvis was living, was it? It wasn't even a known diagnosis. Not many people even know about it today.

No, Dr. Peter Beighton didn't even come up with the (diagnostic screening tool for EDS) until long after Elvis Presley died.

As amazing as it may seem, I'm the only person in the United States who had the autopsies of both Elvis Presley and [aviator and businessman] Howard Hughes and their medical records, and was able to interview their physicians who took care of them. So I felt obligated to put these into books. I don't care whether anybody buys the books or not, but I do think these cases are marvelous cases, and I think these are icons and heroes of the last century, and somebody needed to write it down, and I'm the only one who had the material.

And you know something? For 50 years nobody cared that I had them. Maybe they still don't, but I've got them in the books now, so it'll be recorded for posterity, and that was my goal … to make sure that history is recorded.

Was EDS responsible for the way Elvis was able to move and dance?

Yes, we've got some pictures in the book, and I think we put the question in there. Can you hold these positions and sing and hold a microphone at the same time? And of course, [most people] can't. [EDS was] why he was able to do those things.

But on the other hand, we [recently had] the Olympics, and some of those Olympic [athletes] couldn't possibly do this if they didn't have these hypermobile joints. Whether they will develop the disease in later life is unknown.

When you're young, and you have these joints that are hyperextended, you can do things that other people can't do.

In your recent book about Howard Hughes’ medical issues, you had written about how Hughes was still very successful in life despite the fact he was in an enormous amount of chronic pain due to his medical conditions. Elvis was in the same predicament, wasn’t he?

Very much so, and I'm hoping that people who have intractable pain syndrome, who have EDS, complex regional pain syndrome, autoimmune diseases and traumatic brain injuries, read these books or at least hear about the books, and get some hope and realize that here are two men who did great things in very disparate fields but were terribly ill. I've had many, many patients who read about Howard Hughes tell me that he was an inspiration to them.

Elvis was in a great deal of chronic pain as a result of his EDS. Is that what led to his addiction to opioids?

Yes, we will never quite know how much of the drug taking that Elvis was doing was him self-treating his medical condition and how much of it was just abuse, but that's just the way it is. You can't quantitate it.

I was actually asked to deal with both of these cases because, back in the 1970s, I was trying to deal with patients who appeared to abuse opioids and other drugs and also had legitimate pain, and that's how I got involved with these cases.

It's an issue to this day, and society can't deal with it. They just refuse to talk about it, refuse to deal with it. You've got one group of doctors who just want to treat the addiction. You've got another group who just want to treat the pain, but you've really got to treat some of both and have doctors who understand both, but at this point in time, it's not happening.

I would love to see these books bring about some rational discussions about opioids and about pain and addiction, but I don't see it happening. I see nothing but controversy, accusation, falsehoods, fabrications. Society and the media can't seem to have rational discussions anymore about these issues, unfortunately.

I think with all of Elvis’ health issues and his subsequent drug addiction, it was almost like the perfect storm, right? He has EDS that's causing him extreme pain. The doctors give him pain medications to try to remedy that, so he can actually perform on stage, but then he’s still not able to perform up to the standards of his fans because of his addiction to those drugs.

He was really in a damned if you do, damned if you don’t predicament.

Yes. Also, these drugs probably caused him to have a terrible traumatic brain injury. We couldn't document it, but I suspect that's what happened. He did have a terrible traumatic brain injury, which accelerated all his other problems.

Yes. Apparently, he had fallen in a bathroom and had injured his head, and that was part of what was going on with him in the last years of his life as well.

Yes, it sure was. So again as you pointed out, it was the perfect storm. That's exactly what happened.

You know what I think is so interesting about these two books that you've written? We as the public have this view of Howard Hughes that he was a recluse because he was eccentric and that was just part of his personality. But he was actually really suffering a great deal from chronic pain.

And it's the same situation with Elvis. When we think about his death, we think he was just a drug addict who took too many pills one night, fell off the toilet and died, right? But Elvis was also living with extreme pain and suffering, and he was likely just trying to medicate himself out of that misery.

In our research studies, I saw four people yesterday who have EDS as well as spinal canal problems, and they're just miserable. I sometimes don't know how Elvis and Howard Hughes and the people I hear from daily, I don't know how they make it, you know? I marvel at it.

I'm hoping that everybody who's got intractable pain syndrome or EDS or traumatic brain injuries reads these books. That's who they're written for.

Why did you think it was important to write for those audiences?

I think that the audiences that we deal with are terribly neglected in society. I hate to say it, but I think people who have intractable pain are disdained by a great segment of the population. They're ignored by the political structure, neglected by the medical profession. I hate to say it, but the people we deal with, somebody has got to look after them.

My wife and I… we've managed to put together a foundation and use our business successes to try to help people, and I think that's not normal either. My study of the best physicians over time have been doctors who stepped up to the plate for people who needed it because nobody else in society is going to.

I feel sorry for all the groups that have been out lobbying their legislators, their politicians, their medical boards, and they get deaf ears. They get nothing but yes, yes, yes, but then nothing happens. The medical profession we have, it doesn't stand up for people with intractable pain syndrome or EDS, and that is because a huge part of the medical profession is based on treating well people or simple problems.

And so these are people in society who are disdained, neglected and abused, and are put in the corner by huge segments of not only society at large and the government, but also by the medical profession itself.

Yes, I understand exactly what you're saying. I've encountered it myself as a chronic pain patient.

I bet you do.

Any final thoughts?

I have read I don’t know how many books on Howard Hughes and Elvis Presley, and almost all of them are antagonistic. They are hostile. They blame somebody. They are looking for something that's bad, okay?

And I don't know whether it's the authors. I don't know whether it's their publishers. I can't tell you, except I know one thing: In my review of Howard Hughes and Elvis Presley, and like I say, I'm the last person who knew their doctors and had any real contact with their physicians and even the media, I don't see all this negativism.

I think people as a group try to deal with the Elvis affair legitimately, honestly and with care, and the idea that somebody should be blamed, somebody should be bad-mouthed, it's just not there.

These are great stories. They're tragic stories, but I think there are an awful lot of positive, really good things that happened to these men and to people who were around them, so I don't think we're going to get anywhere dealing with some of these issues with just total negativism.

And I think the whole situation, if you read it, is somewhat uplifting and motivating. We are here to try to help our fellow man and women have better lives, and I think there's a lot of that in both of these men.

Donna Gregory Burch was diagnosed with fibromyalgia after several years of unexplained pain, fatigue and other symptoms. She was later diagnosed with chronic Lyme disease. Donna covers news, treatments, research and practical tips for living better with fibromyalgia and Lyme on her blog, FedUpwithFatigue.com. You can also find her on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest.

All proceeds from sales of “The Strange Medical Saga of Elvis Presley” will go the Tennant Foundation, which gives financial support to Pain News Network and sponsors PNN’s Patient Resources section.

A Different Perspective on Disbelief

By Carol Levy, PNN Columnist

I was watching a 2009 episode of Law and Order. The plot line revolved around a fetus who had Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS). They talked about the trials the fetus would face if born, because he would have “fragile” skin that could tear at the slightest touch.

Never once was chronic pain, a major aspect of the disorder, even mentioned. I wondered why they ignored such an essential part of living with EDS. Could it be that the idea of chronic pain is foreign to most people, including scriptwriters? Not a novel thought by any means, but then I took the idea further.

Most of us know what a sprained ankle, aching tooth or thumb hit with a hammer feels like. It hurts like heck, but we know it will go away. We do as much as we can to make it stop as quickly as possible. Pain is something our bodies and minds abhor. And rightfully so.

For most people, acute pain is short lived. It does not disable us, at least not for more than a few hours or days. It is not debilitating. It does not take over our lives.

But for some of us, the pain lingers and becomes chronic. It changes our lives irretrievably. Our experience is antithetical to what most people know and how they experience pain. We still expect them to understand, but way too often they don't. And it is upsetting, even maddening, when they don’t.

But maybe it is not merely that they don’t “get it.” Our minds and bodies are created in such a way that we are meant to turn away from pain. Maybe that also means to turn away from the horrible idea that there can be pain that does not heal and does not go away.

It is easy to think – and hope -- that if I explain my chronic pain to those who deny it, who call me a hypochondriac or malingerer, that they will ultimately come around and understand.

Not understanding, or being unwilling to understand, always seemed to me as a failing in the other person; a lack of empathy or compassion. But maybe it is more than that. Maybe it is a biological and psychological imperative. To accept that pain can be chronic is anathema to the way our minds and bodies are programmed to respond to pain.

Not an excuse, but maybe a way to understand when someone says, “I don’t believe you.”

Carol Jay Levy has lived with trigeminal neuralgia, a chronic facial pain disorder, for over 30 years. She is the author of “A Pained Life, A Chronic Pain Journey.”  Carol is the moderator of the Facebook support group “Women in Pain Awareness.”