ER Opioids ‘Extremely Unlikely’ to Lead to Addiction
/By Pat Anson
Many patients in pain have horror stories to share about their experiences in hospital emergency rooms, where they’ve been treated as drug seekers and denied opioid medication.
“I had a broken arm and was given nothing for pain when leaving the emergency room,” one patient told us. “They now treat everyone like a drug seeking addict even if you have legitimate pain!”
“My last ER visit has caused me PTSD. It was awful they put me in a room and turned the light off and left me there for hours,” said another.
“The emergency rooms are horrible,” said a patient with a fractured rib. “I wasn’t even asking the ER for meds. I wanted an x-ray or something because I was in excruciating pain.”
Are fears about opioid addiction justified? A new study found that the risk of developing opioid use disorder after being treated with intravenous opioids in the ER is quite low – less than one-tenth of one percent (0.002%).
Out of 506 patients treated with IV opioids in two Bronx emergency rooms, only one met the criteria for long-term or persistent opioid use six months later.
“These data suggest that the use of IV opioids for acute pain among opioid-naive patients is extremely unlikely to result in persistent opioid use,” wrote lead author Eddie Irizarry, MD, an emergency medicine physician at Montefiore Medical Center.
“Opioid naïve” means the patients had never taken opioids before or only used the drugs infrequently.
The study, recently published in The Journal of Emergency Medicine, defines persistent use as filling six or more opioid prescriptions in the 6 months after an ER visit, or an average of one prescription per month.
The most frequently reported IV opioid administered in the ER was morphine (94%), followed by hydromorphone (4%) or a combination of both morphine and hydromorphone (2%). The researchers noted that most of the morphine doses were “relatively modest.”
After being treated in the ER, 63 of the patients (12%) received an opioid prescription on discharge.
The researchers cautioned that opioids should be used “judiciously” and that many ER patients could be treated with non-opioid analgesics such as acetaminophen. But they could find no evidence that IV opioids should be routinely denied in the ER.
“We are not aware of compelling data to support denying parenteral opioids to opioid-naïve patients who are suffering from severe acute pain,” said Irizarry.
The research mirrors the findings from a 2017 Mayo Clinic study, which found that the risk of long-term opioid use is lower for ER patients than it is for patients treated in other medical settings. In the Mayo study, 1.1% of opioid naive patients became long term users. That compares to 2% of patients who were prescribed opioids in non-emergency settings.
