CEO Shooting Exposes Deep Faults in U.S. Healthcare System
/By Crystal Lindell
Over the last few weeks I’ve been privately lamenting the fact that we just completed an entire presidential election cycle with almost zero mention of health insurance from either of the major party candidates.
Healthcare costs impact so much of my life and the lives of loved ones, yet it seems like neither the Republicans or Democrats even noticed. Just a few years ago, there were conversations about the possibility of Medicare for All or at least a public option from the U.S. government – but in 2024, both of those things seemed to have been forgotten.
My credit was destroyed long ago by tens of thousands of dollars in medical debt, all of which were incurred when I was still working full-time and when I still had what most people would consider “good” health insurance.
Now, as a freelancer, I’ve just gone without. I did try to look into private health insurance, but it costs too much and covers too little, so I decided that it made more sense to live without health insurance for the last 2 years. I pay cash for doctor appointments and prescriptions while trying my best to avoid hospitals.
I’m not the only one I know struggling with health insurance and healthcare costs though.
My grandma’s Medicare Advantage plan recently kicked her out of a short-term rehab facility because they said she was fit to go home – despite the fact that she could not even stand up to use the toilet yet.
My sibling had to put off a needed procedure until they could get a new job that offered better insurance.
And my mom can’t go on Social Security yet because she’s still a couple years too young for Medicare, and the Social Security payments would mean she’d lose her Medicaid eligibility.
In fact, the only people I’ve ever met in real life who like the health insurance industry are people who work for the health insurance industry. And I have long said that the only people in America who like their own health insurance are the people who’ve never really had to use it
Over the last few years I’ve become even more radicalized on the issue. I’ve come to realize health insurance in America is an active scam. That’s in large part because it’s usually tied to your employment.
The problem is that when someone gets truly sick, one of the first things they often lose is their ability to work. The entire healthcare system is set up to make most people pay for insurance when they’re well, and then to make them lose their insurance as soon as they might need to use it. That’s a scam. Especially as insurers rake in billions of dollars in profit annually while running this scam.
Plus, if you somehow manage to hold on to your job and your insurance after getting sick, the insurance companies often won’t pay for all your healthcare costs. They do their best to deny as many claims as possible.
Vigilante Justice
Last week, UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was shot in a targeted assassination in New York. Luigi Mangione, a 26-year-old who suffered from chronic back pain, has been arrested for the crime.
It was the kind of violent act that just a few years ago I think most Americans would have bristled at. Vigilante violence isn’t usually something that finds mainstream acceptance here.
But as healthcare costs continue to ruin people’s lives, while politicians ignore all the suffering, the reaction to the shooting wasn’t universal condemnation – it was glee. All over the internet, people rejoiced at the news. And there’s already merchandise supporting the alleged shooter being sold online.
There’s no doubt that Thompson’s decisions as CEO of the largest private health insurer in the world have resulted in people dying. Afterall, UntiedHealthcare has the highest claim denial rate in the industry.
And make no mistake, claim denials kill people. It means that patients who needed life-saving treatments couldn’t get them. Yet the U.S. justice system would never make Thompson face any form of criminal liability for those deaths.
Human beings crave justice though. And when the law stops giving it to them, they seek it elsewhere.
Thompson’s shooting – and the public reaction to it – are predictable. In a system where a well-paid insurance executive will never even be arrested, the desire for justice doesn’t evaporate.
Most Americans understand this already. We live it everyday, and we know healthcare costs in the United States are unsustainable.
It’s the politicians – who actually have the power to fix any of this – who refuse to see the truth. They all receive large donations from the insurance industry to make sure we never get so much as a public option.
But truth demands to be seen. You can’t hide it forever. And people will instinctively feel joy when it is revealed – even if that joy is in response to a vigilante assassination.
I’m not hopeful that our politicians will acknowledge these truths now. But it would be in their best interest to do so.