Louisiana’s New Law Shows How Opioid Phobia Ushered in Abortion Restrictions
/By Crystal Lindell
I’ve long said that pain medication is a “my body, my choice” issue – and a new Louisiana law really drives home the connection between opioids and abortion regulations.
The state passed a law back in May that re-classifies mifepristone and misoprostol – two medications taken in tandem to induce abortion – as Schedule IV controlled substances, the same category as Xanax and Valium.
Misoprostol is prescribed for a variety of situations, including reproductive health emergencies, as well as miscarriage treatment, labor induction, or intrauterine device (IUD) insertion. Because it is also used for chemically-induced abortions, the drug has long been a target of pro-life advocates in Louisiana, where abortion was criminalized in 2022.
Under the new law, possession of either mifepristone or misoprostol without a prescription from a specially licensed doctor is a felony punishable by up to 5 years in prison.
It’s the biggest sign yet that the War on Drugs has officially collided with abortion rights in our post-Roe V. Wade world. Indeed, as states continue to restrict access to opioids and other medications, it becomes more and more obvious that pain patients and abortion rights advocates share a common fight.
The state law goes into effect Oct. 1, but a report in the Louisiana Illuminator highlights how it’s already causing "confusion and angst" amongst healthcare professionals.
In anticipation of the new law, some Louisiana hospitals are already removing mifepristone from their obstetric emergency care carts, where it would be used in the case of hemorrhage after delivery to stop bleeding and save a mother’s life. Removing it from the cart and locking it up is a standard practice at hospitals for controlled substances, but it means that mifepristone can’t be accessed immediately during emergencies.
“Doctors and pharmacists are scrambling to come up with postpartum hemorrhage policies that will comply with the law while still providing proper medical care for women,” the Illuminator reports.
Note how the idea of not complying with the law – which many doctors have personally disagreed with – doesn’t even seem to enter the realm of possibility. It’s the full manifestation of “just following orders” justification.
One doctor theorized that the pending law also likely explains why pharmacists had been “pushing back” when she prescribed misoprostol for outpatient miscarriage management.
“They’ve been calling her to request clarification on why she prescribed the medication, and one pharmacy refused to fill the prescription,” the Illuminator reported. “She had to send that patient to a different pharmacy. Her patients often travel hours to see her, and she regularly has to call in misoprostol to help them manage care at home.”
Pharmacies pushing back on doctor's prescriptions? That sounds familiar. In fact, many patients who take necessary medications like hydrocodone for pain or Adderall for ADHD have numerous stories to share about pharmacists trying to block their prescription from being filled.
And while it may not seem like it at first, all those points of friction in the process do lead to doctors refusing to prescribe controlled medications because they don’t want to deal with the hassle and risk of going to prison. It’s an outcome that I’m sure the Louisiana lawmakers who pushed the legislation through are hoping for with abortion-related medications.
Making a Choice
It’s a grave mistake to think we can isolate things like pain medication restrictions from the rest of healthcare. Every new restriction that takes options away from doctors and patients paves the way for the next one that comes down the pike.
Pro-choice advocates sometimes try to claim abortion medications shouldn’t be restricted because they are “life-saving.” However, many other controlled substances are also life-saving and we don’t see the pro-choice movement standing up for patients who need them. Those patients are also making a “choice” about their own bodies.
Untreated ADHD is proven to lower your life expectancy. Untreated and under-treated pain can cause a number of complications, from needless suffering and withdrawal to longer recovery times and even death when patients are forced to find pain relief on the unsafe black market.
Controlled substance laws make it much more difficult for patients who need medications labeled with that classification to get them – and people do die as a result. Just as people will likely die as a result of the new law in Louisiana.
My concern is that the general public has been too quick to accept medication restrictions as necessary when they are promoted as solutions to things like the “opioid crisis.” I fear that people will start to believe that mifepristone and misoprostol are actually worthy of the classification of “dangerous controlled substance,” just as they believe medications like hydrocodone and Adderall are.
Unfortunately, if pain treatment is any indication, I don’t expect many doctors or hospital administrators to be willing to risk personal punishment for the health of their patients. I have personally seen doctors refuse opioids to dying patients because they “might get in trouble.”
I expect most medical professionals and hospitals will comply with the new Louisiana regulations without much tangible push back.
On the other hand, maybe there is a small place for hope here. Imagine a world where classifying more drugs as controlled substances helps medical professionals and the public understand why these classifications are problematic – legal frameworks that lack sound medical reasoning. Unfortunately, I don’t see that happening any time soon.
In the meantime, pro-choice advocates could learn a lot from those of us who have been on the front lines of the drug war for decades. If we want to have any hope of victory, we all need to join together to fight all restrictions on bodily autonomy – whether it’s related to reproductive health, pain management, or any other health condition.
We must join forces now. The longer we wait, the more emboldened governments will become in making choices for us.
